Tuesday, 5 December 2017

Reverse your usual expectations

Most music is written in 'keys'. Keys are specific groups or 'scales' of notes that a composer can choose from when writing music. There are two main types of keys: major and minor.

Think of weddings, celebrations and Christmas: much of the music written for these will be in major keys.

Think of remembrance services, funerals and Halloween: much of the music written for these will be in minor keys.

Arguably, the association of major keys with lively occasions and joyous feelings (and minor keys with sombre occasions and sorrowful feelings) is almost as much about cultural expectations and conditioning as about the characteristics of the keys themselves.

For example, in Russia and Eastern Europe lively and energetic pop songs (and even advertising jingles) are written in minor keys. Indeed, when asked why this was the case, a Russian musician said that the major keys were reserved for 'inexpressible sadness': a very dramatic reversal of Western European expectations indeed!  

Antonin Dvořák, one of the most accomplished and popular musicians of the 19th century (and, as a Czech, heavily influenced by Eastern European musical traditions and practices), also challenged Western European expectations concerning the use of keys.

In the Third Movement of his 4th Piano Trio in E minor, Op. 90 the slow and sadly reflective opening and closing sections are in a major key and the lively and energetic middle section is in a minor key. This, at least to Western ears, reversal of the usual use of keys not only adds an exotic richness to the sound and texture of the music but also (given the subtly dissonant emotional undertones of the minor key) weaves a melancholic thread into the otherwise brightly dancing liveliness of the movement's middle section.

Dvořák was able to add subtle but telling emotional depth to his Trio by simply reversing the expected order and function of his music's keys. This straightforward but not always emulated musical "slight of hand" provides a small but telling hint as to why many people consider Dvořák a particularly accomplished and creative composer.

We can uncover significant insights and (like Dvořák) gain superior solutions by reversing our usual expectations (be these perceptual, cultural or social, or bound-up with traditional practices and ways of doing things).

Here are some questions to consider:
  • What would be the outcome if you reversed the expected order of your actions or methods and techniques? 
  • What would be the outcome if you travelled in the reverse direction to that expected? 
  • What would be the outcome if you focused on the past rather than the future (or vice versa)?
  • What would be the outcome if you reversed your expectations of an individual or a group?
  • What would be the outcome if you chose to be optimistic where you were usually pessimistic (or vice versa)?
  • What would be the outcome if you reversed your expectations of yourself?

No comments:

Post a Comment

I would really like to hear people's views and ideas about music and creativity - just leave a quick message here.